Subtitle: “He’s Just Not Into You” messes with my head.
Sub-subtitle: “I’m just overthinking.” (Grey’s Anatomy)
When I was 15 and a freshman in high school I went on my first date. I was so smitten with the boy. He came and picked me up, we went to Chili’s, I ordered what he said his mom usually got because I was shy and uncertain. He brought me home. He called the next night. It was fated.
I remember a month later I found out he had started dating a girl a year older than he. He was a junior, she was a senior. I listened to Brandy sing “Have You Ever” over and over again. (Don’t judge me.) My heart hurt.
When I was 16 and none-the-wiser, I went out with that boy again. This time was a double date. Afterwards we went to the house of the other boy and watched Friday and it was ohhh so romantic. I swooned over Ice Cube. The boy tried to unhook my bra. (FAIL.) And then he took me home.
Shortly thereafter he wrote me a note and handed it to me between classes. “I’ll always love you,” he wrote, as he went about explaining to me that his best girl friend, whom I had never met, had confessed her love for him. And if they didn’t try things now, he’d always wonder.
It wasn’t until the end of that school year that I got my first kiss. From Mr. Athletic. We had gone on a walk on the beach and he’d laid it on me. It was my welcome to the world of sandy kisses. He carried me back down the beach to the house. We kissed more on the couch in the room with our friends. And then I went to bed thinking, How am I going to get rid of this guy?
I had liked him for months but now? Now that I was sure he liked me? Now he was smitten and I was not. Over instant messenger he asked me to be his girlfriend. His girlfriend! I could’ve been somebody’s lady friend. Instead I told him I really didn’t want to date someone over the summer. Because, obvy, the summer after my sophomore year was going to be booked, you know. He didn’t listen to Brandy but I hear he got good and drunk.
My freshman year of college was the year that I got good and drunk. At a fraternity function. I was dressed as a flapper and my date, my old friend from preschool who I’d always crushed on a little bit, was Mafia attired. We pre-gamed, we danced, we hit up a booth in the corner of the place and we kissed and we kissed and oh lord I needed a ride home and someone to tell me the next day whether that kissing actually happened or not. Which my date’s best friend was more than happy to do, as he told me how much my date had liked me and he was so shy and I needed to reassure him by calling him some (or, er, calling him back). But I didn’t, and he didn’t step up, and there was nothing lost. (Except maybe for a little dignity which had likely been spent on purple jesus.)
Two years later I was back on a dance floor in a frat house with a boy named Ben whose name I think I liked more than Ben himself. He tongue attacked me and tried to [in the bathroom] mack on me but all in all I left with most of my dignity and my phone number still kept to myself. (A trend I would later recognize.)
Post-college I experienced a lot of boredom. This is also known as no dating potential. Casually recognized as just plain no date invitations. (Um, I was used to it, so who are we kidding?)
I found an attachment to a guy friend I’d met that meant spending most nights at his house. We never did do anything but talk and sleep and spend inordinant amounts of time together. And he, Mr. Beat, was a guy that soon became someone I wanted to beat over the head with a stick. I was attached. To him and to his conversations. (And now, I can honestly say, not to the way he looked.)
One day, some time later, we did finally kiss. It had followed jaeger, produced zero sparks, and taught me a lesson that Garth Brooks has tried many times before to instill in me. That being thanking God for unanswered prayers.
The search continued. After pina coladas laced with moonshine, I found myself on a Sunday funday in August of 2007 on the backporch of the Slumdog Bachelor’s house realizing what the words “good kisser” meant. I got up off that porch and into my car that night to go home and counted down the years it’d been since anyone had good and kissed me. The next morning before work I told the roommate of the little bit of dignity I’d spent the night prior and she decided the following week to test my best kisser theory. (No harm done; Slumdog Bachelor never was on my radar to begin with.) I continued to act all Judgy McJudgerson on guys that followed. Guys who continued to go without my number. Someone I’d known in college, Dreadlocks who had been my super secret special crush, McHottie’s brother Otter. I continued to kiss ‘em and leave ‘em and Oh! They never called because they had no way to! And I didn’t want them to anyway! So all’s fair, right?
Well, if we’re being honest, they never tried to get my number. And the one or two that did have it? Yea, they never tried to use it.
So while saying no big deal, I wasn’t that into them either, can be both helpful and true, it really makes me think. It’s pretty simple: I’m just looking for the guy who’s my exception just as much as I am his.
“I don’t want to be ‘sort of dating’ someone. I don’t want to be ‘kind of hanging out’ with someone. I don’t want to spend a lot of energy suppressing my feelings so I appear uninvolved. I want to be involved.” He’s Just Not That Into You by Greg Behrendt and Liz Tuccillo.